This term paper presents two alternative development concepts originating from different cultural contexts and social positions, both aiming at generating another view on development including a conscious handling of the environment, social equality and a happy life in fullness. Conducting a comparative analysis of the two alternative development concepts – "Buen Vivir" (Ecuador) and "Gross National Happiness" (Bhutan) – the author tends to identify core aspects of both concepts and expound the countries’ strategies of implementation as well as their success and failures in doing so in order to eventually make a statement about the concepts’ potentials and limits.
At a glance
- Grade: 1.3 (1.0 is the best grade)
- Compares Buen Vivir in Ecuador with Gross National Happiness in Bhutan
- Examines the Yasuní-ITT Initiative as an Ecuadorian implementation case
- Analyzes Bhutan’s Driglam Namzha code of ethics as a policy example
- 43 sources in the bibliography
Table of Contents
1. Introduction
2. Buen Vivir
2.1. Context of emergence
2.2. Content of Buen Vivir within the Ecuadorian Constitution
2.3. Planned implementation
2.4. Actual implementation: Yasuní-ITT-Initiative
3. Gross National Happiness
3.1. Context of emergence
3.2. Content and Measurement
3.3. Planned implementation
3.4. Actual implementation: Driglam Namzha
4. Comparison
4.1. Similarities
4.2. Differences
5. Conclusion
Objectives and Themes
This comparative analysis examines Buen Vivir in Ecuador and Gross National Happiness in Bhutan as alternatives to development approaches centered on economic growth. It asks what potential and limits the two concepts have by investigating their cultural origins, principles and implementation strategies.
- Critiques of economic growth as a measure of development
- Andean and Buddhist influences on ideas of well-being
- Constitutional principles, policy plans and measurement
- The Yasuní-ITT Initiative and environmental protection
- Driglam Namzha and cultural preservation in Bhutan
- Similarities and differences between the two approaches
Excerpt from the Book
2.1. Context of emergence
The term Buen Vivir emerged for the first time within the intellectual discourse in Latin America in line with a research project of the Instituto Latinoamericano de Investigaciones Sociales between 2000 and 2002. The indigenous anthropologist Carlos Viteri Gualinga showed that there is neither a word for development existing in indigenous languages nor an explicit perception of development within the communities in Amazonia, but rather a holistic view on objectives of human efforts (Villalba 2013: 1429). The latter are about searching for and creating material and spiritual conditions to construct and preserve Buen Vivir, which is defined as harmonious life (Viteri 2002: 2). The Spanish wording Buen Vivir used as the translation of the Quechua term Sumak Kawsay is inasmuch delusive as it is not possible to build an antipode to Sumak Kawsay in the sense of bad living. Buen Vivir rather is about harmony and perfection of the biotic community that permits living in fullness based on mutual respect and reciprocity (Yampara 2010: n.p.). To better understand this concept one should look at its ancestral, Andean roots in an animistic ontology (Fatheur 2011: 17; Schmid 2014: 15). Following a biocentric rather than an anthropocentric posture with a utilitarian view on nature, Andean communities belief in the interconnectedness and mutual dependency of all life and thereby recognize intrinsic values in environment (Gudynas 2011: 443). These ideas of Buen Vivir have been – along with great participation and commitment of citizens and indigenous organizations – incorporated in the new Ecuadorian Constitution. The latter was approved in 2008 within the framework of a political process of left progression as a reaction to dominating western capitalist principles of living better dismantling neo-liberal policies (Acosta 2009: 219; Walsh 2010: 15, 20). This so called ‘citizen revolution’ tends to construct a sustainable, organized and dynamic version of economic, political, environmental and social systems, decolonize thinking and thereby achieve a shift in the notion of development (Walsh 2010: 16). Therefore, the major aim of the President Rafael Correa’s government is to create a link between socialism and Buen Vivir to strengthen society, labour and life in all its variations (Senplades 2013: 24)
Chapter Summaries
1. Introduction: The introduction critiques growth-based measures of development and sets out the comparative, literature-based approach to Buen Vivir and Gross National Happiness.
2. Buen Vivir: This chapter traces the concept’s Andean origins, its place in Ecuador’s constitution and its planned implementation. It examines the Yasuní-ITT Initiative as an example of environmental policy.
3. Gross National Happiness: This chapter explains the Bhutanese concept’s Buddhist background, its measurement framework and policy plans. It also discusses Driglam Namzha as an example of cultural policy.
4. Comparison: The comparison considers the concepts’ shared holistic orientation alongside differences in their origins, measurement and approaches to cultural diversity.
5. Conclusion: The conclusion reflects on the potential and limitations of context-specific alternatives to growth-centered development.
Keywords
Buen Vivir, Gross National Happiness, Ecuador, Bhutan, alternative development, quality of life, economic growth, sustainability, indigenous worldviews, Buddhist values, environmental rights, Yasuní-ITT Initiative, Driglam Namzha, comparative analysis
Frequently Asked Questions
What is this work about?
It compares Ecuador’s Buen Vivir and Bhutan’s Gross National Happiness as alternative approaches to development and quality of life.
What are the central themes?
The central themes include well-being beyond economic growth, cultural traditions, environmental protection, public policy and the implementation of alternative development concepts.
What is the main research question?
The work asks what potential and limits Buen Vivir and Gross National Happiness have, considering their principles and implementation.
What research method is used?
The author conducts a comparative analysis based on existing literature and governmental documents, examining the concepts and selected policy examples.
What does the main discussion cover?
It covers each concept’s origins, content and planned implementation, followed by an implementation example and a comparison of similarities and differences.
Which keywords characterize the work?
Key terms include Buen Vivir, Gross National Happiness, Ecuador, Bhutan, sustainable development, quality of life and environmental rights.
How is the Yasuní-ITT Initiative used in the analysis?
It serves as an Ecuadorian case for examining how Buen Vivir’s environmental principles relate to public policy and resource extraction.
What is Driglam Namzha’s role in the discussion?
It is discussed as a Bhutanese code of etiquette and an example through which to examine cultural preservation and national identity under Gross National Happiness.
How is Gross National Happiness measured?
The work describes a framework of four pillars, nine domains and 33 weighted indicators covering areas such as health, education, culture and ecological diversity.
- Arbeit zitieren
- Silvana Vialova (Autor:in), 2018, Theory and practice of two alternative development concepts. Growth versus quality of life, München, GRIN Verlag, https://www.hausarbeiten.de/document/913382