Hausarbeiten logo
Shop
Shop
Tutorials
De En
Shop
Tutorials
  • How to find your topic
  • How to research effectively
  • How to structure an academic paper
  • How to cite correctly
  • How to format in Word
Trends
FAQ
Zur Shop-Startseite › Philosophie - Praktische (Ethik, Ästhetik, Kultur, Natur, Recht, ...)

Are lotteries fair and if so, when should they be used?

A critical analysis of John Broome's and Tim Henning's arguments

Titel: Are lotteries fair and if so, when should they be used?

Essay , 2018 , 8 Seiten , Note: 1,00

Autor:in: Andjelika Eissing-Patenova (Autor:in)

Philosophie - Praktische (Ethik, Ästhetik, Kultur, Natur, Recht, ...)

Leseprobe & Details   Blick ins Buch
Zusammenfassung Leseprobe Details

How should we decide about whom to give access to medical treatment, like transplanting organs? How should study places be allocated as fairly as possible? Should only the strongest men be chosen for military service? When there are sufficient resources to satisfy all potential claimants, the implementation of allocating processes might be simple, but what does distributive justice require when resources are scarce? When should we discriminate between people, i.e. decide on the basis of special considerations, and when is it better to choose randomly? Philosophers have provided different theories of distributive justice and argue in distinct and partly conflicting manners particularly about the use of lotteries. Regarding allocation processes, this means that the allocator and the claimants do not know in advance who will receive the good and who will not. Thus, a lottery may ensure that nobody can be preferred on grounds of special considerations. This paper focuses on the question: Are lotteries fair and if so, when should they be used? An answer to this question is not only relevant for individuals and everyday-life decisions, but also in very broader terms for political, societal or economic questions concerning distributive fairness, with probably global impacts.

Leseprobe


At a glance

  • Grade: 1.0 (1.0 is the best grade)
  • Critical comparison of John Broome’s and Tim Henning’s arguments
  • Examines three strategies for defending Henning’s Lottery Requirement

Table of Contents

I INTRODUCTION

II WHAT ARE LOTTERIES?

III LOTTERIES ARE REQUIRED BY FAIRNESS: JOHN BROOME

IV LOTTERIES ARE NOT REQUIRED BY FAIRNESS: TIM HENNING

V IMPLICATIONS AND CONCLUSION

Objectives and Themes

This essay examines whether lotteries are fair and when they should be used to allocate scarce resources. It critically compares John Broome’s and Tim Henning’s arguments about fairness, competing claims, and random selection.

  • Distributive justice and scarce resources
  • Lotteries as allocation procedures
  • Fairness claims and equal chances
  • Broome’s distinction between fairness and the general good
  • Henning’s objections to the Lottery Requirement
  • Practical implications for allocation decisions

Excerpt from the Book

LOTTERIES ARE REQUIRED BY FAIRNESS: JOHN BROOME

John Broome provides a justification for selecting people randomly (which in this context is tantamount to using lotteries) in allocative decision-making and suggests a quite intuitive theory of fairness. Therefore, Broome shows that lotteries are not only a cheap and effective procedure, but additionally and more importantly, that they are fair, even if special considerations about people, as race, gender, social worth, age, level of happiness etc., are not exactly balanced. If a good (or a bad) is indivisible, or cannot be distributed equally, and if all possible candidates have (roughly) equal fairness claims, in some occasions a decision-maker is justified to give everyone an equal chance of receiving the good by using a lottery. (Broome 1984: 40 ff.)

According to Broome, a fairness claim gives the candidates in question some claim to a good and so authorizes them to be treated fairly in relation to others with equal fairness claims, which does not simultaneously imply a right to the good (Broome 1984: 43). Because of Broome’s missing definition of “claims”, their source and implications, it is not exactly clear what he actually means by “some claim to the good”, without implying a right to it, which might be problematic for the proper understanding of fairness claims. As some of the candidates will not receive the good, their claims cannot be satisfied, wherefore it might be more appropriate to define fairness claims as giving all candidates a claim to be treated fairly and to be as strongly considered as all the others, and not a claim to the good itself. Unfortunately, Broome is not entirely clear about that, which will turn out to be the basis for Henning’s misunderstanding, analyzed later in this paper.

Fairness, as a relational matter, basically requires to treat all parties concerned equally. That would mean either to divide the good equally, or to give it to nobody. But especially when a good is indivisible, such an equal treatment is not possible. By giving the good to some, and not to others, some unfairness is inevitable. Supposing that a few candidates are in need of an antidote against a poisoning, but the antidote suffices only for one of them, it would not help anybody to divide it equally, so that all would die, only because fairness requires equal treatment. Therefore, the best we can do is to treat all candidates equally in some different way, by at least giving them all equal chances at receiving the good through a random selection process (lottery). Broome’s principle to treat (roughly) equal claims equally by using a lottery thus brings at least some fairness into an unavoidably unfair situation and allows a partial satisfaction of claims. (Broome 1984: 45 f.)

Chapter Summaries

I INTRODUCTION: The introduction presents the problem of allocating scarce resources and asks whether lotteries are fair and when they should be used.

II WHAT ARE LOTTERIES?: This section explains lotteries as procedures with uncertain outcomes and introduces their use in allocation.

III LOTTERIES ARE REQUIRED BY FAIRNESS: JOHN BROOME: The author examines Broome’s account of fairness claims and equal chances, including the relationship between fairness and the general good. The discussion also considers objections and the scope of random selection.

IV LOTTERIES ARE NOT REQUIRED BY FAIRNESS: TIM HENNING: This section examines Henning’s objections to three arguments for a Lottery Requirement and assesses their relationship to Broome’s position.

V IMPLICATIONS AND CONCLUSION: The final section draws together the arguments and considers how moral principles and the circumstances of individual cases affect allocation decisions.

Keywords

lotteries, distributive justice, fairness, resource allocation, random selection, fairness claims, equal chances, indivisible goods, general good, Lottery Requirement, impartiality, moral principles

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the essay about?

It examines the fairness of lotteries as a way of allocating scarce goods.

What are the central themes?

The main themes include distributive justice, equal claims, random selection, impartiality, and the general good.

What is the main research question?

The essay asks whether lotteries are fair and, if so, when they should be used.

What method does the author use?

The author uses philosophical argument and critical analysis to compare John Broome’s and Tim Henning’s positions.

What does the main discussion cover?

It explains how lotteries work, examines Broome’s argument for their use, and considers Henning’s objections to a requirement to use them.

Which keywords characterize the essay?

Key terms include distributive justice, fairness claims, equal chances, random selection, and the Lottery Requirement.

Why are indivisible goods important to the discussion?

When a good cannot be divided among claimants, a decision-maker must consider how to treat competing claims fairly.

Which arguments for the Lottery Requirement does Henning examine?

He considers the Surrogate Satisfaction Account, the Procedural Account, and the Ideal Consent Account.

How does the essay relate fairness to the general good?

It examines Broome’s distinction between duties of fairness and other considerations, and asks how their relative importance affects allocation decisions.

Ende der Leseprobe aus 8 Seiten  - nach oben

Details

Titel
Are lotteries fair and if so, when should they be used?
Untertitel
A critical analysis of John Broome's and Tim Henning's arguments
Hochschule
Universität Salzburg
Veranstaltung
Ethics - Theoretical and Applied
Note
1,00
Autor
Andjelika Eissing-Patenova (Autor:in)
Erscheinungsjahr
2018
Seiten
8
Katalognummer
V437642
ISBN (eBook)
9783668780989
ISBN (Buch)
9783668780996
Sprache
Englisch
Schlagworte
ethics lotteries lottery random selection fairness claim fair fairness claims allocation allocation process good goods scarce medical treatment military service conscripts transplanting organs claimaint allocating process distributive justice resources justice discrimination discriminate special considerations random randomly select randomly required John Broome Tim Henning fair process dice coin rolling a dice tossing a coin urn allocator claimants prefer receive veil of ignorance probabilities probability decision-making decision intuitive effective decision procedure balance indivisible equal equally equal claims decision-maker fairness claim treat fairly satisfy satisfaction satisfied divide unfairness chance chances
Produktsicherheit
GRIN Publishing GmbH
Arbeit zitieren
Andjelika Eissing-Patenova (Autor:in), 2018, Are lotteries fair and if so, when should they be used?, München, GRIN Verlag, https://www.hausarbeiten.de/document/437642
Blick ins Buch
  • Wenn Sie diese Meldung sehen, konnt das Bild nicht geladen und dargestellt werden.
  • Wenn Sie diese Meldung sehen, konnt das Bild nicht geladen und dargestellt werden.
  • Wenn Sie diese Meldung sehen, konnt das Bild nicht geladen und dargestellt werden.
  • Wenn Sie diese Meldung sehen, konnt das Bild nicht geladen und dargestellt werden.
  • Wenn Sie diese Meldung sehen, konnt das Bild nicht geladen und dargestellt werden.
  • Wenn Sie diese Meldung sehen, konnt das Bild nicht geladen und dargestellt werden.
Leseprobe aus  8  Seiten
Hausarbeiten logo
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
  • Shop
  • Tutorials
  • FAQ
  • Zahlung & Versand
  • Über uns
  • Contact
  • Datenschutz
  • AGB
  • Impressum
  • Vertrag widerrufen