In the years from 1911 to 1934 Mexico witnessed fifteen presidents1 appearing and vanishing
after short periods of rule. The political, economic and social reasons for such a rapid change
in governmental affairs will be discussed in this essay. Governments can be defined as
“institutions responsible for making collective decisions for society. More narrowly,
government refers to the top political level within such institutions” (Hague R., p. 5). It is
suitable to evaluate the question of governmental survival on the background of an official
period of four years till 1926 and from then on of six years. This makes it possible to
recognise that the rulers in Mexico during the first 33 years following the revolution were not
capable of remaining in power for a whole term and/or did not survive their removal from
office in a literal sense. All those governments never reached the political stability in order to
consequently produce a lasting regime. This essay will firstly deal with factors which can be
applied as reasons for all regimes to some degree such as competition for power, opposition,
failure to reform and a discontent population. Secondly some remarkable impediments weigh
more heavily on specific regimes such as personal incompetence or foreign and clerical
pressure, which made it even more difficult for them to persist. To answer the addressed
question of this work, I will focus on President Madero, Huerta, Carranza, Obregón and
Calles in order to represent convincing explanations for their failure to survive, exemplifying
arguments for all regimes till Lazaro Cardenas. The reasons, which should be considered of great albeit varying significance for the failure of
all the disappointing and short lived rulers succeeding the dictator Díaz, will be discussed in
the first part of this paper. Power struggles within the ruling elite, severe opposition,
economical difficulties and the failure to reform, a discontent population and its resulting
political obstacles caused the problem of unsolved political instability which was those
governments undoing. [...]
1 15 presidents from Francisco Leon de la Barra (interim) 1911 to Abelardo L. Rodriguez (interim) 1932-1934;
http://www.northcoast.com/~spdtom/rev3.htm
At a glance
- Examines the presidencies of Madero, Huerta, Carranza, Obregón and Calles
- 27 sources in the bibliography
Contents
1. Introduction and scope
2. Power struggles and opposition
3. Reform, economic conditions and popular discontent
4. Leadership, foreign pressure and religious conflict
5. Conclusion
Aim and Topics
This essay examines why the first revolutionary governments in Mexico struggled to remain in power. Focusing on five presidents, it considers how political rivalries, opposition, reform, economic conditions and external pressures affected governmental survival.
- Elite power struggles and military loyalties
- Revolutionary opposition and armed rebellion
- Agrarian and labour reform
- Economic pressures and popular discontent
- United States influence and foreign relations
- Church–state conflict and the Cristero rebellion
Excerpt from the Book
Why did the first revolutionary governments in Mexico fail to survive?
The reasons, which should be considered of great albeit varying significance for the failure of all the disappointing and short lived rulers succeeding the dictator Díaz, will be discussed in the first part of this paper. Power struggles within the ruling elite, severe opposition, economical difficulties and the failure to reform, a discontent population and its resulting political obstacles caused the problem of unsolved political instability which was those governments undoing.
Regimes were doomed to fail because power struggles emerging inside the ruling elite made unobstructed rule impossible. Many revolutionaries betrayed their loyalty to a specific leader or a revolutionary ideal in order to achieve executive power. Such opportunistic allies made it difficult for a president to secure his authority and political stability, leaving the government vulnerable to further attacks and without the necessary support to act efficiently. The unfortunate choice of political partners made the regimes susceptible towards unforeseeable fast power changes. President Franciso Madero, who came to power in 1911, relied on the wrong people to be his associates. Calero, for instance, being an intimate friend of the dictator Díaz, had changed sides to become Madero´s ally. “Rebels and conservatives alike agreed that with Calero, Madero had picked for his cabinet one of the most opportunistic politicians in the history of the country” (Ruíz R., p. 151). Other ambitious man like Reyes, an ex-Porfirian general, however unsuccessfully, left the government vulnerable to further attacks. Reyes “plotted and schemed to make himself president, preferably by election but by force if necessary” (Cumberland C., p. 190) but his dreams were shattered when his supporters abandoned and Madero jailed him. It surely weakened the Madero administration to a certain extent because Reye´s “...overweening desire to occupy the presidential post stimulated reaction, encouraged disloyalty, and led to dissension and revolt” (Cumberland C., p. 190). Furthermore the blind trust of the president in the wrong man facilitated his own destruction. Madero confidently asked General Huerta to defend his regime. Being an opportunistic general, he betrayed Madero and his trust in the leader of his loyalist forces through the ´Ten horrible days` and took the chance to gain the most influential position in Mexico. Noticing the political change and trying to save their own position, most of Madero´s early supporters abandoned him, withdrawing the necessary basis to reign the country and to uphold the president´s own standing. “Only two of his governors, José María Maytorena in Sonora and Venustiano Carranza in Coahuila, rejected Huerta´s tutelage” (Ruíz R., p. 152).
Chapter Summaries
1. Introduction and scope: The essay sets out its question about governmental survival and identifies the presidents used to examine it.
2. Power struggles and opposition: The discussion traces shifting loyalties within the ruling elite and considers the challenges posed by revolutionary movements and rebellions.
3. Reform, economic conditions and popular discontent: The essay examines agrarian and labour policies, economic difficulties and the expectations of peasants and workers.
4. Leadership, foreign pressure and religious conflict: The author considers Huerta’s leadership, relations with the United States and tensions between the revolutionary state and the Catholic Church.
5. Conclusion: The essay brings together its explanations of instability and contrasts earlier administrations with the presidency of Lázaro Cárdenas.
Keywords
Mexican Revolution, governmental survival, political instability, revolutionary governments, Francisco I. Madero, Victoriano Huerta, Venustiano Carranza, Álvaro Obregón, Plutarco Elías Calles, agrarian reform, armed opposition, United States–Mexico relations, Cristero rebellion
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the essay about?
It examines why Mexico’s first revolutionary governments struggled to survive after the fall of Porfirio Díaz.
What are its central topics?
Its topics include elite rivalries, armed opposition, reform, economic conditions, popular discontent, foreign pressure and religious conflict.
What is the primary research question?
The essay asks why the first revolutionary governments in Mexico failed to survive.
What method does the author use?
The author develops a historical analysis using published accounts and examples from selected presidencies to compare pressures on different governments.
What does the main discussion cover?
It considers factors shared across administrations before examining challenges associated with particular rulers, including leadership, foreign relations and clerical opposition.
Which keywords characterize the essay?
Key terms include Mexican Revolution, political instability, agrarian reform, armed opposition, foreign pressure and the Cristero rebellion.
Which presidents receive particular attention?
The essay focuses on Francisco I. Madero, Victoriano Huerta, Venustiano Carranza, Álvaro Obregón and Plutarco Elías Calles.
How does the essay address land reform?
It discusses competing expectations of land redistribution and the approaches taken by successive governments to agrarian policy.
Why is the Cristero rebellion discussed?
It provides an example of the conflict between the revolutionary state’s secularizing measures and religious opposition during the Calles administration.
- Arbeit zitieren
- Lucia Schuster (Autor:in), 2002, Why did the first revolutionary governments in Mexico fail to survive, München, GRIN Verlag, https://www.hausarbeiten.de/document/13834