Hausarbeiten logo
Shop
Shop
Tutorials
De En
Shop
Tutorials
  • How to find your topic
  • How to research effectively
  • How to structure an academic paper
  • How to cite correctly
  • How to format in Word
Trends
FAQ
Go to shop › Philosophy - Practical (Ethics, Aesthetics, Culture, Nature, Right, ...)

Our concept of art in light of the strata theory

Unser Kunstbegriff im Lichte der Schichtentheorie

Title: Our concept of art in light of the strata theory

Essay , 1996 , 11 Pages

Autor:in: Dr. Wolfgang Ruttkowski (Author)

Philosophy - Practical (Ethics, Aesthetics, Culture, Nature, Right, ...)

Excerpt & Details   Look inside the ebook
Summary Excerpt Details

Dieser Aufsatz ist eine Fortsetzung der schichtenästhetischen Arbeiten des Autors, die in deutscher Sprache erschienen sind.
Es wird versucht, ein "synthetisches Modell" der stratologischen Kunstkonzepte von Nicolai Hartmann und Roman Ingarden für einen ontologischen Vergleich von vier ganz verschiedenen Gegenständen zu nutzen: einen Gebrauchsgegenstand, ein kunstgewerbliches Objekt, sowie für je ein Kunstwerk der Literatur und der Musik.
Die dabei gewonnenen Einsichten über die besondere Daseinsstruktur von Kunst lassen überraschende und in ihrer philosophischen Begründung neue Aufschlüsse über Grenzen der Wirkungsmöglichkeit "moderner" Kunstarten zu.
Der Aufsatz beginnt und endet mit Reflexionen über die zeitliche Begrenztheit und eingeschränkte Gültigkeit unserer Kunstkonzepte überhaupt.

Excerpt


Contents

1. Comparing the Arts and Defining Art

2. A Comparative Model of Artistic Strata

3. Ontological Principles and Strata Theories

4. Contemporary Art and the Limits of the Concept of Art

Aims and Themes

This essay asks whether a philosophically grounded theory can support a productive comparison of the arts and what such a comparison can reveal. It uses a synthetic model of artistic strata to examine different kinds of objects and to test the reach of established concepts of art.

  • Phenomenological and ontological approaches to art
  • Hartmann’s and Ingarden’s theories of artistic strata
  • Comparison of a chair, a vase, a novel and a sonata
  • Material, order, objects, movement and expression
  • The relationship between artistic media and their expressive possibilities
  • The applicability of established concepts of art to contemporary practices

Excerpt from the Book

OUR CONCEPT OF ART IN LIGHT OF THE STRATA THEORY

In order to clarify and illustrate the character of and relationship amongst strata, let us first turn to a concrete example (see scheme) and briefly compare a commodity, e.g. a chair, with an art object in the broadest sense of "applied arts", e.g. a vase. Let us further compare two art objects in a more narrow sense: a novel, as an example of literature as well as of the particularly complex representative arts, to which also painting belongs, and a sonata as an example of the special position of music.

1. All four are dependent on MATERIAL, by which they are, so to speak, "anchored to the concrete world", enabling them to "appear" in it - in contrast to abstract concepts, for instance scientific ones. The material of the first two imagined objects, wood and clay, is given in a simple manner, and the same applies to the tones (sounds) of music. The material of the novel, however, is not paper and ink, but rather words with their meanings. Language itself is, as Scheler(7) would say, "objectified intellect", that is multistratified. Thus the relationship of strata in the literary work of art is more complex than in all other kinds of art.

2. But we encounter material only in a particular ORDER, especially in objects designed by human beings. Material is shaped(8) toward the appearance of the next stratum. Its shape depends on both neighboring strata, the potential of the material - e.g. with iron one cannot achieve the effect of transparency - and the intention of the third stratum. Since the latter can appear only in a particular order of the material, we must view order as a stratum (the second) of its own - and not just as a quality of the first stratum (of the material).(9)

3. What appears through the first two strata? Is it sufficient to say "the OBJECT" (chair, vase, objects and characters in literature)? As early as in the second stratum, we encounter the "chair-form" of wood and "vase-form" of clay. An inhabitant of another planet, however, who has never sat and never seen anyone sitting, would never recognize the FUNCTION of these forms. -

Chapter Summaries

1. Comparing the Arts and Defining Art: The essay introduces the problem of comparing different arts and considers why a philosophical account of art is needed. It presents stratification theory as a means of examining works of art and their relationships to other objects.

2. A Comparative Model of Artistic Strata: A chair, a vase, a novel and a sonata serve as examples for examining successive strata, from material and order to movement, expression and exemplary significance. The comparison explores how different media support different forms of artistic experience.

3. Ontological Principles and Strata Theories: The discussion considers the relationships between more concrete and more abstract strata and contrasts Hartmann’s and Ingarden’s approaches. It also examines the implications of their theories for comparing artistic forms.

4. Contemporary Art and the Limits of the Concept of Art: The essay tests its account against contemporary poetry and painting. It closes by questioning how far an established concept of art can be extended while remaining useful.

Keywords

strata theory, aesthetics, ontology of art, phenomenology, Nicolai Hartmann, Roman Ingarden, comparative arts, literature, music, material, expression, abstract painting, concrete poetry, artistic media

Frequently Asked Questions

What is this essay about?

It examines how a theory of artistic strata can help compare works of art with one another and with other human-made objects.

What are its central themes?

Its themes include the ontology of art, stratification, artistic media, expression and the limits of established concepts of art.

What is the main question?

The essay asks whether a philosophically grounded theory permits productive comparisons among the arts and what can be learned from such comparisons.

What method does the author use?

The author uses a comparative ontological and phenomenological analysis based on a synthetic model of strata associated with Hartmann and Ingarden.

What does the main discussion cover?

It traces several strata across a chair, a vase, a novel and a sonata, considering how material, order, objects, movement and expression function in each.

Which keywords characterize the essay?

Key terms include strata theory, aesthetics, ontology of art, artistic media, literature, music and expression.

Why are a chair and a vase included alongside a novel and a sonata?

They provide points of comparison for examining the differences between a practical object, an object of applied art and works of literature and music.

How does the essay approach music?

It considers music’s distinctive position within the strata model, including how movement and expression can be experienced without the ordinary presentation of objects.

How does the essay address contemporary art?

It considers concrete poetry and abstract painting when asking whether a concept of art developed through strata aesthetics can accommodate newer artistic practices.

Excerpt out of 11 pages  - scroll top

Details

Title
Our concept of art in light of the strata theory
Subtitle
Unser Kunstbegriff im Lichte der Schichtentheorie
Author
Dr. Wolfgang Ruttkowski (Author)
Publication Year
1996
Pages
11
Catalog Number
V82652
ISBN (eBook)
9783638889063
ISBN (Book)
9783638904643
Language
English
Tags
Unser Kunstbegriff Lichte Schichtentheorie
Product Safety
GRIN Publishing GmbH
Quote paper
Dr. Wolfgang Ruttkowski (Author), 1996, Our concept of art in light of the strata theory, Munich, GRIN Verlag, https://www.hausarbeiten.de/document/82652
Look inside the ebook
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
  • Depending on your browser, you might see this message in place of the failed image.
Excerpt from  11  pages
Hausarbeiten logo
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
  • Shop
  • Tutorials
  • FAQ
  • Payment & Shipping
  • About us
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Imprint
  • Withdraw Contract